We Got Thanksgiving From the British. Here’s What Else We Should Take.

By Tom Henkenius, founder of Henkey's

This Thursday, most of us will sit down to a holiday we got from a boatload of English people.

You might need to throw out your mental picture from the third grade. Those Pilgrims, in black suits with a buckle on everything, mostly didn't exist.

A couple of years ago I read Nathaniel Philbrick's Mayflower: A Story of Courage, Community, and War, and I came away thinking the people on that boat were an interesting lot: stranger, more colorful and, frankly, a lot smellier than the ones we cut out of construction paper.

The Pilgrims Weren't Who You Think

Start with the clothes. When someone in Plymouth Colony died, the court took an inventory of everything they owned, including their clothes, often down to the color. Those lists don't read like the image we've developed in popular culture.

William Brewster, the colony's church elder, died in 1644 and left behind green breeches, a red cap, a violet coat and a blue suit. Not a black suit and no belt buckle in sight. Black was expensive to dye and was mostly saved for Sundays and formal occasions. The buckles came later. Actually, Victorian illustrators added them in the 1800s because they looked quaint, which, in fact, is the same reason Santa got buckles.

Only one Mayflower passenger ever sat for a portrait painted from life: Edward Winslow, in London, in 1651. He's wearing black and white. That's not because Pilgrims always dressed that way. By 1651, black had become fashionable in London. Even the one real picture we have shows a man dressed for the city he was visiting.

1651 portrait of Mayflower passenger Edward Winslow in black and white clothing, holding a letter from his wife Susanna
Edward Winslow, painted in London in 1651. The only portrait of a Mayflower passenger made from life. Pilgrim Hall Museum, Plymouth, Massachusetts.

He's also holding a letter, and you can still read the line at the top: "From yr loving wife Susanna." Winslow lost his first wife that first brutal winter in Plymouth, and Susanna White had lost her husband too. About six weeks later, in May 1621, they married. It was the colony's first wedding, and a civil one. Governor William Bradford presided, noting that nothing in the Gospel said a minister had to be involved. It's the detail from Philbrick's book that stuck with me. These weren't the stiff, joyless people from the paper cutouts. They grieved, they got on with living, and thirty years later Winslow had himself painted holding her letter.

The Craziest Part of the Mayflower's Voyage

The Mayflower carried 102 passengers across the Atlantic in 66 days. That's the part everyone knows. What gets left out is how long they'd already been on board.

The trip was supposed to start in summer with two ships. The second one, the Speedwell, kept springing leaks. They actually set off twice and had to return to port. Eventually everyone crammed onto the Mayflower and finally left England on Sept. 6.

Some passengers had boarded in July. And landing didn't end it. Through that first winter, they rowed ashore to build houses during the day and slept on the ship at night. The Mayflower wasn't fully emptied until the end of March. Some of them lived on that ship for the better part of eight months.

All 102 passengers crammed into a deck between the crew and the cargo hold: no windows, a ceiling about five feet high and no latrines. Basically, a crawl space.

Nobody bathed. And not just because of the boat. In England at the time, people widely believed that soaking your body in water was dangerous, because it opened you up to disease. Additionally, getting fully undressed to do it seemed immodest.

The Wampanoag, the native tribe who lived where the Pilgrims landed, had no such fear. They washed in rivers and streams regularly, and their accounts suggest the new arrivals didn't smell great. They also thought it was disgusting that the English blew their noses into a cloth and then put it back in their pockets.

Still, the English didn't think of themselves as dirty. They had a different system: clean linen. The shirt against your skin was supposed to draw the grime out of your body, so a fresh one meant a clean you. A crisp white collar and cuffs told everyone you took care of yourself.

The Pilgrims had the science backward, but they understood that what touches your skin all day matters, and that looking put together is a signal people read.

What the British Did Next

England eventually came around on water. And when it did, London built a men's grooming tradition that's still open for business.

In 1730, a young man from Menorca named Juan Famenias Floris opened a grooming shop on Jermyn Street. It's still there, still run by his family, and it's the oldest English retailer of fragrance and toiletries. Truefitt & Hill opened in 1805, and Guinness World Records recognizes it as the oldest barbershop business in the world.

What strikes me about that tradition is how unshowy it is. The British ideal isn't the guy with the twelve-step routine. It's the guy who looks well put together without looking like he tried. A good shave, a decent haircut, a fragrance you notice only when you're standing close.

So I asked Harry Aaronson, co-founder of the London grooming brand Heath, how British guys pull off that effortless look. He wasn't convinced they all do. Some of his friends manage it, he said, but maybe I'd just been spending my time in London's chic neighborhoods. Take me outside the city and I might think I was back in the States.

(Ask a Brit for a compliment about his country and he'll talk you out of it.)

But he did point to one real difference: fragrance. British men, he says, like the old-fashioned scents that haven't changed in decades, the ones their grandfathers wore. Americans chase trends and sweeter notes, lots of vanilla mixed with something smoky.

"The UK, we're a bit more simple."
— Harry Aaronson

That happens to be how we think about grooming at Henkey's, too.

Three Things to Take Home

I also asked Harry what American guys should steal, think about and borrow from British grooming. His answers were short and very British.

Steal: the wet shave. Harry admits he's biased. "I like to wet shave, I think it's something really nice and enjoyable," he says. A proper wet shave with a real shave cream starts the day right, or freshens you up before a night out.

Think about: smaller sizes. Harry can't get over how big American bottles are. On trips to the States, he says, three products can turn his backpack into a 15-kilo haul back to the hotel. A giant bottle that sits in your shower for a year or two doesn't stay fresh, and most products are meant to be used within about a year of opening. Buy the size you'll finish.

Borrow: the sarcasm. Not technically grooming, but he insisted.

"I think British people do sarcasm very well. Americans don't always get it."

And I'd add two lessons from 1620, one from the Wampanoag and one from the Pilgrims.

  • Bathe. The Wampanoag washed as a matter of routine, and according to one biography, Tisquantum, who the Pilgrims knew as Squanto, tried to get them to start. They didn't listen. You should.
  • Respect the clean shirt. A fresh shirt still does more for how you look and smell than most guys give it credit for, especially at a long holiday dinner in a warm house.

Pass the Gravy

Four hundred years later, we kept the turkey and dropped the buckles.

Thursday will be loud. A full house, an oven that's been running since dawn, at least one uncle with opinions about the stuffing. So before the mayhem starts, take ten minutes for yourself: a hot shower, a proper shave, a clean shirt.

That, Harry says, is the whole point of grooming.

"It's about taking time out of your day to look after yourself. It's adding a nice moment of calmness for yourself."

And when your uncle gets going, a little British sarcasm never hurt.

Happy Thanksgiving.

FAQ

Did the Pilgrims bathe?

Rarely. In 17th-century England, many people believed that soaking the whole body in water was unhealthy and that undressing to do it was immodest. They relied on washing their hands and face and on changing into clean linen shirts and undergarments.

Did the Pilgrims really wear black clothes and buckles?

No. Estate inventories from Plymouth Colony list clothes in green, red, violet, blue and other colors. Black was mostly worn on Sundays and formal occasions, and the buckled hats and shoes were added by 19th-century illustrators.

Where did the Pilgrims live their first winter?

Mostly on the Mayflower. After landing in November 1620, they rowed ashore to build houses during the day and returned to the ship at night. The last passengers didn't move ashore until March 1621.

What is the oldest barbershop in the world?

Truefitt & Hill in London, which opened in 1805. Guinness World Records recognizes it as the oldest barbershop business in the world.

How long do grooming products last after you open them?

Many products are meant to be used within about a year of opening, and some sooner. Look for the small open-jar symbol on the label with a number like "12M," which tells you how many months a product is good for once opened.

What is British grooming known for?

A long tradition of wet shaving, barbers and fragrance houses, many still operating in London, and an ideal of looking well put together without obvious effort.